Dr. M Blatstein's Blog

THE SENTENCING HEARING: YOUR CLIENT’S CHANCE TO ADVOCATE FOR THEMSELVES – WITH THEIR JUDGE

Today, Is Your Client Prepared to Speak with Their Judge? What is the ‘1’ Thing that Differentiates Them from Everyone Else Entering Their Judge’s Courtroom?

Your Sentencing Hearing is a pivotal moment that could profoundly impact your future. You need to recognize that the Judge has already assessed your Presentence Report, which was created by your Probation Officer, and carefully considered your case. Additionally, the Judge has received a recommendation regarding your sentence. It’s imperative to understand that this hearing does not have to be a mere formality but an opportunity to present yourself in the best possible light and potentially influence your outcome. Take it seriously, and prepare accordingly. I hope this video is helpful and gives you a starting point to work with.

Facing America’s Criminal Justice System for the first time is a life-altering, surreal, and frightening experience. The importance of preparation and working with your legal team before the presentence interview cannot be overstated.

Once this has all been completed, as an attorney, you’ve prepped your client right up to their sentencing hearing.

Then, after sentencing, there still are a lot of fears and unknowns as they face either their self-surrender date or are remanded at that time.

Attorneys know the law, but the nuances of navigating through Federal Prison aren’t part of a traditional legal defense. This requires a unique set of knowledge and skills that interest those assessing a person’s access to freedom.

STAKEHOLDERS are part of the system that controls everything that happens following the guilty verdict and until you’re released from the Federal Bureau of Prisons. They are responsible for keeping society safe by reducing criminogenic needs for those who will eventually be released. From the Judge to the BOP Case Manager and Unit Team, to the Probation Officer on Supervised Release, and then possibly back again to the Judge to get off Supervised Release early, at each stage, these STAKEHOLDERS make decisions that impact your client’s future.

Realize that even if you’re doing everything right from the start, the only person you can control is – you, and still, there will be disappointments. Therefore, being prepared at every stage, keeping your eyes open with a positive attitude, and continuing to add to your Reentry Plan are all ingredients needed for getting home to your loved ones. Remember: No Cell Phones, No Trouble, and No Infractions.

YOUR STAKEHOLDERS

In this video, I introduce you to your STAKEHOLDERS, who will be making decisions that determine and impact your immediate future. Some of these you will meet personally, while others, such as the BOP Staff located at the BOP Designation Center in Grand Prairie, TX, you will never meet. These two groups have in common that they will, for lack of a better term, profile you based either on (1) your INDICTMENT and Presentence Report or (2) Your Personal NARRATIVE, if it’s included with your Presentence Report and Indictment. Which do you suppose will portray you in the best light? I hope the video provides some clarity.

1.   Your Judge, who already knows that;

  • Your Attorney is paid to keep you out of prison or, at best, spend the least time “in prison”.
  • The Probation Officer will conduct their interview, draft the Presentence Report, and recommend your sentence and placement to the court based on your interview. Currently, all they know about you is the Narrative provided by the DOJ through their Indictment of you – this, you can change.
  •  The Prosecutor wants another conviction in his/her file. Currently, all they know about you is also the Narrative provided by the DOJ.
  • The DOJ wants Jail time.
  • But your Judge knows nothing about you – and only Your NARRATIVE can begin to change this, starting with 1st) Helping the Judge Understand Who You Are – and why You Deserve Leniency – Selling your Luxury Cars, Homes, and other stuff if You Have Financial Penalties, 2nd) What Changed in Your Life – That Caused You to Break the Law? 3rd) Invest In Yourself – You Can’t Change the Past, But You Can Change Your Future, start by writing your Story or Narrative.

2.     Your Attorney, until now, also knows nothing about your background, but their time is mostly spent on your legal defense.

3.     The Probation Officer will conduct your Presentence Interview and then write the official Presentence Report. But a week or so before your Presentence Interview, your attorney could provide your Probation Officer with your,

I. Copies of all of your Personal Identification and Biographical Background Information

II. NARRATIVE,

III. REENTRY/RELEASE Plan and answers to the,

IV. Answers To The FSA SPARC-13 Assessment – ‘Questions,’ with them all woven into one document. This does not replace your ‘Interview,’ but it will help save the Officer some work (Sample Probation Presentence Interview Intake Form) while giving them time to know you before you meet in person. You also demonstrate to them that you have done your preparation.

  • Why be prepared with answers to the Assessment Questions? When you arrive at your 1st meeting with your Case Manager, these Assessments must be done and completed for your FSA Programs and Earned Time Credits (ETC) to be offered and then counted – without you taking the Assessment Survey, the programs cannot be offered.
  • During the interview, they can now ask questions and get to know you more personally.
  • Some may appreciate your efforts and become advocates since they are overworked and have no time.

4.     The Prosecutor wants a conviction and only knows about you through the DOJ’s Narrative or your Indictment. Your Narrative may sway them, too.

5.     The BOP Designation Center in Texas places you into a BOP Prison without ever meeting you.

6. Your Probation Officer during Supervised Release. To date, all they know about you is the Narrative released by the DOJ through their Indictment. Your Narrative and Release Plan can change that and your life.

CLIENT PREPARATION: THE WORK YOU DO – IS ADVOCATING FOR YOURSELF

The Personal Narrative, Reentry-Release Plan, and answers to the SPARC-13 Assessment Questions (as you are expected to answer these questions when you first arrive, you might as well become familiar with them early), are written as one document and weaved into the Presentence Report when provided to your Probation Officer, a few weeks before your Presentence Interview.

Here, the defendant has accepted responsibility, expressed remorse for the victim(s) pain, suffering, and how it has impacted them and agrees with the court about the seriousness of the crime without minimizing it.

  • The caveat is that the defendant must put time and effort into writing their Narrative, Allocution, and Reentry Plan because their future depends on it being honest, pure, and from the heart.

PERSONAL NARRATIVE. Writing your story through Your Narrative tells the Judge how you came to this point in your life. This is an arduous, self-reflective experience for you to go through, forcing a face-to-face with your innermost thoughts. This is your autobiography (of you and those around you), the good, the bad, and the ugly. It may require you to enlist someone with federal sentencing mitigation experience to guide you in drafting your narrative, but this is the story of your client’s life and requires their participation. This short 3-4 minute video provides another way to think about when writing your Narrative.

18 U.S.C. § 3553 – Imposition of a Sentence

  1. NATURE and CIRCUMSTANCE You want to include: 1) What led you to do this, 2) How did you get involved, and 3) What was your involvement? [check that your involvement reflects what is in the official Presentence Report].
  2. HISTORY and CHARACTERISTICS Here you want to include 1) Your remorse, 2) How you ruined your victim’s lives, 3) Show what you’re doing to change and improve yourself regarding rehabilitation (NA, AA, GA, Therapy, etc.) and paying restitution – if you can, 4) Where there was a positive or negative family life – explain this, 5) Traumatic event – review with details, 6) Good things you’ve done, explain with examples, 7) Show Judge your Future Plans not to come back, and 8) Cooperation = Substantial Information that does not implicate another 8a)Rule 35. Correcting or Reducing a Sentence, or 8b) Offenders who cooperate with the government in its efforts to prosecute others can receive credit for their “substantial assistance” in at least two ways.
  • Taking weeks to months to complete can result in a distilled version of yourself that is honest and pure, where you feel Remorse, Accept Responsibility, and Identify with the Victims of the Crime You Perpetrated.
  • Mention if you have already started taking these before your Indictment or Presentence Interview (if applicable AA, NA, Gambling, or Sex offense) therapy and forensic (per your attorney, for example, Dementia, there is only ‘1’ Prison Nationwide with a very limited number of beds), therapy sessions.
  • If the resulting Narrative or Your Story – is quite the opposite of the DOJ’s Indictment Narrative, where you sounded like ‘America’s Most Wanted’, you did a Great Job!

REENTRY/RELEASE PLAN EXAMPLE.  Include that you realize you need to learn from the FSA Risk Reduction Programs and implement their lessons into your daily life. Then expand on an appropriate theme, “Since my indictment, arrest, criminal charge, plea hearing, trial or guilty plea, presentence investigation, and sentencing process, I had the time to think about all that I have done. I made BAD decisions, except it shouldn’t be about ME – It’s about MY Victims and What I did. This is most important, as I must Prove my Remorse and my Efforts to Change and Accept Responsibility for The Pain I caused to my victims, the community, my family, and myself. To the court, I do not want to be here again – I have learned a hard and humbling lesson.

If you are currently taking FSA Programs for AA, NA, Gambling, or a Sex Therapy Program, where applicable when released, you want to continue the Therapy and Rehab for AA, NA, Gambling, or Sex therapy rehab. sessions. Write this.

You also have copies of your Social Security Card, Driver’s License (if expired, it needs to be updated with a new test likely), and Birth Certificate. You are grateful to be moving into a home with a support structure. While you have been self-employed forever, you have a letter from a friend willing to hire you, “all I have to do is let them know, as they are expecting my call from me.” “As you see, the letter was also a character letter that I initially provided.”

This YouTube covers Self-Advocacy or everything you can do before your Presentence Interview and then while incarcerated to help you expedite your way to freedom. While this sounds simple – It’s Not. You will be faced with many days of frustration and disappointment, and BOP staff who appear to be there just to give you a hard time. On the other hand, there will be those who care and will, over time, surprise you in good ways, yet unseen. While nothing can or is guaranteed, please use no cell phones, keep busy with constructive activities and non-fiction reading, and document everything that you you for your record. This video provides helpful content.

At the same time, you can also plan to be self-employed again if your role in that business was not part of your criminal charge. Then everything that goes into a traditional business plan, including what you would present to a bank, should be professionally (not handwritten, not expensive) put together, as your Probation Officer will want to see this during or before your Supervised Release.

ALLOCUTION. You may begin by writing (in your own words) something like this…, “I am embarrassed and humbled to be standing here – since my indictment had the time to think about all that I have done, I didn’t recognize how BAD my decisions were, but Now I realized it’s Not About Me. It is about MY VICTIMS, What I did, and What I must do – to make it right. Please listen to this Short but direct YouTube.

Several memorable Statements/Allocutions that positively impacted these Judges,

  1. “No punishment will be enough. If I could go back and change everything, I would.”
  2. I am persuaded that the defendant is sincere and demonstrates insight into the crime.
  3. Allocution is very important, “I’d like to have a conversation with the defendant.” 
  4. I want him/her to apologize to the victim and their family, mainly if they are in the courtroom.
  5. “Allocution, however, changes this when I see the defendant has insight into the harm they have done,” when I see they have insight into this.”
  6. “I am looking for remorse and insight as to why he did what he did and what he is doing to ensure that it doesn’t happen again.

As you stand at your sentencing hearing, nervous, anticipating the conversation with your Judge (your Allocution), you may also realize that writing your narrative has been an unexpectedly cathartic experience. Speaking from the heart could influence the court and ‘may’ impact your sentence…

CHARACTER REFERENCE LETTER. These are letters to one’s character; they know that you have broken the law and have known you for a long time. Should an employer be willing to write a letter that states they are still willing to rehire you after release from prison due to your ‘character and skills’ – that is a Great letter and should be included.

The ‘writer’ of a Character Letter states that they’ve known you for many years and are aware that you are in trouble and facing federal criminal charges and that you feel terrible about what you did.  “We went to college together, and this is so out of character,” and they know that you are so remorseful. Further, as someone who is close to you and part of your support system, they want to assure this court that the defendant won’t be back in front of this judge again because we will be looking out for them in the future and hold them accountable. The video is short but goes into the do’s and don’ts of what goes into a Character Letter. Also, a great Character letter may be a letter that includes that a person will be willing to rehire you after your release due to your character, knowledge, and skills. In this video, I lay out the “dos and don’ts” of what to include in Character Reference Letters.

NOW,are you Better Prepared to Speak to The Judge at Their Hearing Regarding…What is the ‘1’ Thing that Differentiates Them from Everyone Else entering their Judge’s Courtroom?